Building a System of Sources of Law and Their Hierarchy
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.71942/b6t3-cz20Keywords:
hierarchy of law, legal force, law-making, legal regulation, Ukrainian legislation, international treaties, EU law, legal conflicts, conflict principles, systematization, legal monitoring, legal expertiseAbstract
The construction of the system of sources of law and the determination of their hierarchy is one of the fundamental issues of modern theory of law, law-making, and law enforcement practice. The purpose of the work is to clarify the theoretical and legal foundations of the hierarchy of sources of law, to determine the legal force of normative legal acts as a key criterion for their correlation, as well as to outline the main mechanisms for overcoming conflicts between different levels of legal regulation. The resolution of such research tasks determines the logic of the presentation of the material in the work: the systematization of doctrinal approaches to understanding the legal force of normative legal acts; the analysis of levels of legal regulation in national, international, and European law; the clarification of the nature of legal conflicts and the mechanisms for their prevention and resolution. The methodology of the research is based on general scientific and specially legal methods of analysis and synthesis, induction and deduction, formal legal, comparative legal, systemic-structural, and hermeneutic methods, which were used to reveal the internal structure of the system of sources of law and to determine the correlation between acts of different legal force. The results of the research showed that the system of sources of law is not a mechanical collection of normative legal acts, but an internally ordered multi-level structure, in which each act occupies a specific place depending on its legal force, the competence of the law-making subject, the subject of regulation, territorial action, and the procedure for adoption. Legal force is understood not only as the formal obligation of the act but also as its place in the hierarchy of sources of law, priority or subordination to other acts, and the ability to generate legal consequences. It is shown that in Ukrainian law, the hierarchy of sources of law has a constitutional and legislative basis. The Constitution of Ukraine has the highest legal force; laws provide primary regulation of the most important social relations; subordinate normative legal acts have a derivative nature; and international treaties of Ukraine form a separate element of national legislation. Special attention is paid to the Law of Ukraine 'On Law-Making Activity', which enshrined the concept of legal force, defined the hierarchy of normative legal acts, and established requirements for their consistency. Practical significance. The results of the research can be used in law-making activities, legal monitoring, legal expertise of draft normative legal acts, systematization of legislation, as well as in judicial practice when resolving conflicts between legal norms. Value / originality. The work substantiates the understanding of the hierarchy of sources of law not only as a formal arrangement of normative legal acts but also as a functional mechanism for ensuring the consistency of legislation, legal certainty, stability of the legal order, and the rule of law in the context of Ukraine's European integration.Downloads
Posted
2026-05-04
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Arxiv Academy
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
